Looking After #numbertwo

Nothing happens unless first a dream. (Carl Sandburg)

In the bar of a Holiday Inn in Ipswich I find myself in conversation with the writer of a popular television drama, when the subject of Twitter comes up:

‘The thing is, Dan,’ he exclaims with a characteristic pause for emphasis or comedy, I could never tell which, ’I don’t want everyone to know when I’m sitting on the toilet.’

He has a point. Though currently this sort of information is only made available if you choose to make it so (­and I’m sure there is an app for that) it is a perfectly rational fear.  When we trace the origins of the internet and observe how it, and we alongside it, have evolved, and where it all seems to be heading, it is not unreasonable to assume that details of this nature, and indeed every other facet of daily life, may eventually be shared or even required by the system. For now, however, if you wish to broadcast  ‘#numbertwo’, it’s up to you.

The Internet is the current tail of our communicative development: from telegraphy through telephony, radio to the personal computer, our connective network systems have evolved since the first remote message exchange. It began in strictly academic circles, developed primarily to assist in the sharing of research and resources. Yet the web always had a human interest; from J.C.R. Licklider’s delightful concept of a ‘Galactic Network’ at MIT in 1962 to Doug Engelbart’s 1969 Stanford research project, the ‘Augmentation of Human Intellect’, it was seen that by making computers talk to each other, to find a common ‘language’ between two machines, we might mirror something of our own development, might learn from it and improve our lives.

Early advancements came about through missives known as ‘RFCs’ (or Request For Comments), initially sent via physical snail-mail (remember that?) then quickly replaced by primitive email. Users would keep each other informed as to how the general infrastructure of the online experience was working and how it could be improved. Just as the concept grew out of our own invention, so it developed and evolved with our own feedback. The development of the Internet was in itself a social network.

We have assimilated these advances linguistically too, so that they seem to fit naturally and grow alongside us. Words such as ‘host’, ‘domain’, even the ancient precaution of a ‘firewall’ all evoke a solid, historical idiom; a brave new world that has such familiar terms in it. ‘Forum’ is a perfect example: the ancient roman marketplace where one could find so much more than just market stalls: sales pitches, entertainments, side-shows, soliciting, and drunken japery as well as nodes of discussion, arguments, opining and pontificating, quite aside from everyday bitching and gossip. Where the early digital lexicon involved many hybrid terms or neologisms, a few of which survive (e.g. ‘blog’, ‘download’, etc.), the mainstay of our virtual vocabulary is drawn from our own preexisting, ‘real’ world. As the ‘appliance’ was to electricity, so is the ‘application’ to the Internet. The ‘architecture’ of the online world has its topographic ‘sites’ created by ‘developers’: all of it sounds like it has been here before.

Of course, as with something like the ‘Hoover’, there are certain brands that dominate a new field and become words in their own right. One of the more significant of these is ‘Google’; itself a misspelling of the word ‘googol’, the expression of the number 10100. Google has always occupied a curious position in the online sphere and has achieved something of Darwinian prominence in its survival and defeat of other lesser search engines and operations: how many ‘Chrome’ users remember the web’s first ‘browser’, ‘Mosaic’? Who now asks that tired old butler ‘Jeeves’…?

When the futurist and inventor Ray Kurzweil was signed up as Google’s Director of Engineering a few weeks ago it seemed to be a moment of great significance. The visionary, the pioneer of technologies such as optical and speech recognition and text-to-speech, one of the great prophets of artificial intelligence and the Cyber Age was officially absorbed into the belly of the beast. The brand, indeed the word, which has infused our daily lives had co-opted the services of this digital dreamer. But nothing happens unless first a dream. The title of Kurzweil’s best-selling book now begins to look like a statement of fact: The Singularity Is Near. The age of super-intelligence is practically upon us; the point at which the global supercomputer has received enough feedback, enough information that it can develop and improve itself so as to be self-governing, even self-conscious; the point at which the machine has learned to mimic human behaviour and subsequently to improve upon it; beyond which anything might be possible.

In a recent issue of Wired magazine, ‘Senior Maverick’ Kevin Kelly writes of this imminent ‘singularity’,­ the eventuality that the robots will ‘take over’,­ in an essay entitled ‘Better Than Human’. In it he includes a visual matrix of new and existing jobs that humans and/or machines can and cannot do. He briefly touches upon the progression of humans towards roles that they, uniquely (‘for now’), can fulfill:

‘ballerinas, full-time musicians, mathematicians, athletes, fashion designers, yoga masters, fan-fiction authors, and folks with one of a kind titles on their business cards.’

He qualifies his tongue-in-cheek list, projecting that ‘of course, over time, machines will do these as well’.  I’m not so sure; after all, the Luddites were wrong.  Fear of unemployment caused by mechanisation, or what economists call the ‘Substitution Effect’, proved unfounded since a conflicting ‘Output Effect’ in fact created work, albeit displacing it. So today there is a shift, a displacement. Kelly’s list seems to echo the less ironic words of the Dalai Lama, that the planet ‘desperately needs more peacemakers, healers, restorers, storytellers and lovers of all kinds’, roles that will remain human long after many others have gone the way of all wires. It is the quintessentially human characteristics that will prevail; curiosity, imagination, innovation, compassion, irony, humour. ‘Drop by drop’, as Chekhov wrote, we ‘squeeze the slave’ from ourselves: our roles become ever more prescribed by the technology we have created and perpetuated, and consequently our introspection increases. The network and its resulting gadgetry is now such an inextricable part of our lives and is so entwined with our evolution that instead of it distancing us from ourselves it is forcefully reminding us that we exist and, hopefully, awakening us as to why we exist.

Feedback loops of all kinds are vital, even those not directly contributing to the development of the Internet itself.  Our online presence stands as a Book of Reckoning; every click and comment defining us.  Supposed anonymity perpetuates a lack of accountability and therefore trawling (or trolling) the ‘bottom half of the internet’ reveals how far from greatness we can sink. But the anonymous, pixelated veil is an illusion; whilst the individual identity seems hidden (for now), this input shapes us all, standing as a record of our thoughts and motivations. It is our collective consciousness made visible, viral warts and all. Leaning towards digital optimism we face a conscious choice and a responsibility to our own self-improvement, to find the good. Tweet as you would be twoten to.

In his 1950 paper ‘Computing Machinery and Intelligence’ the mathematician and computer scientist Alan Turing upgraded his initially proposed question, ‘Can a computer think?’ to ‘Can a computer do what we (as thinking entities) can do?’ Now that the answer to that question is almost ubiquitously ‘yes’, the questions we face are ‘What is it we can do that the machine can’t?’; ‘What is it the machine may never be able to do?’ Go to the toilet? To laugh? Perhaps to love?

27 Comments

Comments on The Junket are now closed. These were left by readers while they were open.

  1. Linda R. 25 January 2013

    After enjoying your work as an actor, it is such a bonus to get a glimpse into an interesting mind. Never stop writing! Thank you!

  2. Nancy B 25 January 2013

    Very well put. Guess that’s why there’s nothing like the good old-fashioned letter via snail mail. I remember Jeeves too! Personally, I liked the sitcom better. You did your homework. Have a great day!

  3. Nadia Diakun-Thibault 25 January 2013

    Excellent piece, Dan. as I’m sure you know, Ray Kurzweil has a new tome “How to Create a Mind.” Pair it with Daniel Kahneman’s “Thinking, Fast and Slow”, and you dive into an ocean of cognitive science and organic brain. While the technology, the very creation of human endeavour, surpasses itself daily, indeed there are things a machine will never be able to do. Would we want them to? How uninteresting might existence become if humans capitulated every aspect of life to a … machine? We make mistakes. Because we make mistakes, and we program machines, they will make mistakes. Perhaps in so distant dystopian scenario, we may realize the biggest mistake humans made was making them far too much in our own image and likeness.

    1. Randy Owens 28 January 2013

      Well put.

  4. Molly Godfrey 25 January 2013

    Technology has become as ubiquitous as the air we breathe, so we are no longer conscious of its presence. – Godfrey Reggio.

    Thought provoking piece. I would argue we need to discover a way to program all of our machines to -stop- “using the toilet” before our planet boils over and/or becomes uninhabitable due to the poisons and toxins leaching/belching from some of them. But that’s another article.

    Your piece certainly sparked my imaginings as to just how a machine might possibly someday, somehow, be able to replace human friendship. The joy one feels at having contributed to an in-person, face to face, audible laugh rather than just an “LOL” on a screen. Hearing the symphony of intonations and melodies of human speech during a discussion. Witnessing the look on someone’s face when they realize you understand them or have caused them to think differently than they might ever have before.

    Autism is on the rise. I have an autistic son. Facial expressions are a constant source of confusion and frustration for him. From what I’ve read, it is thus for most other autists as well. Are we witnessing the evolution of the human race to creatures unable to appreciate, let alone understand, face to face contact with fellow human beings? Curious.

    Enjoyed the read. Thanks.

    1. Sabina Petra 26 February 2013

      Wow, that is an unsettling and sad thought. I think that as long as we long for love, music and storytelling, we will always long for contact…hopefully.

  5. Katherine Barrett Baker 26 January 2013

    Lovely, and thought provoking writing…and I was reading this piece and remembering the Katharine Hepburn/Spencer Tracy movie “Desk Set.” I’m so old…or rather would like to think, an old soul! Thank you:)

  6. Jennifer Riley 26 January 2013

    @ drama writer: I never considered anyone would ever tweet from a restroom. Several years ago some person said the Internet is like passing notes in class. I suppose the restroom is the logical place to catch up.

    1. Randy Owens 28 January 2013

      I’m not surprised that someone would tweet from a restroom. After all, I have too many times been the unfortunate audience to someone’s soliloquy on his cell phone in the next stall. How one could do that with his voice reverberating from the special acoustics found in a typical restroom is beyond me.

  7. Jennifer Riley 26 January 2013

    If there were an edit function (hint, hint), I would add the Internet needs a function where I can drag a favorite piece of writing, hit “create movie,” select the settings, actors and camera angles, and thus by-pass formal movie making.

  8. The Teacher Geek 27 January 2013

    “It is our collective consciousness made visible, viral warts and all. Leaning towards digital optimism we face a conscious choice and a responsibility to our own self-improvement, to find the good. ”

    I teach children who are at an age where they are just beginning to create their digital imprints. As such, I feel the need to always advise them to use the internet for good, not for evil. Young people will always find ways to express love, hate, remorse, sadness and joy, whether it’s through passing notes in the hall, or via Tweets. Technology is a tool, a vehicle, a conduit, by which humans find their like-minded selves.

    Strangely, Twitter led me to this literary gem. Thank you.

  9. The Fly 28 January 2013

    Very impressive writing.

    I’ll be reading this junket of your for as long as it exists.

    Fly

  10. Jaclyn 28 January 2013

    Any time I read a piece on technology and human interaction, I hear portions of Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451. He would have liked this discussion. The line that I’ll go to bed thinking about tonight is “Our online presence stands as a Book of Reckoning; every click and comment defining us.” Wonder what this comment and the countless others I’ve offered over the years say about me. Thanks for an interesting discussion.

  11. PW 28 January 2013

    Thank you for such a well-written piece, I sincerely enjoyed reading it. Working in information sciences, it is interesting to see how this technology has changed how we communicate and share information. There is a preference to instead of sharing information over e-mail or in print, someone will post a link to Twitter, which if deemed relevant will get “favorited”, “retweeted” or shared by some other means. There is a risk that if you’re not “plugged in” to these dominant social networks, you’re missing out on relevant conversations. Does this mean that if you’re in certain fields, you must be a part of these networks, or does it mean that these networks are usurping the conversation? I don’t know what the right answer is, and as the world continues to get more and more interconnected, I can imagine the answer will change.

    Thank you again for sharing your thoughts. I enjoyed your performance immensely when I saw you on stage in New York and I enjoyed reading this and the others articles you’ve written here as much. Please keep writing and I look forward to seeing you again on stage or screen soon.

  12. LawLib 28 January 2013

    Enjoyed this very much.
    Thinking about the digital lexicon as an example of the perpetual evolution of meaning. We continually re-purpose language to suit our contemporary culture. The rapid expansion of Internet access perhaps required the new vocabulary to gain more rapid acceptance.

    1. LawLib 29 January 2013

      Just thought to share this from the American Dialect Society (hope it’s ok to use authority from across the pond): 2009 Word of the Year is “tweet”; Word of the Decade is google” http://www.americandialect.org/2009_word_of_the_year_is_tweet_word_of_the_decade_is_google

  13. caroline weese 30 January 2013

    i’m old enough to remember the huge,room encompassing computers;the “new world” which both excited and frightened. As with all things, we adapt,accept,even appreciate. Singleness, the constant communicating via a device, however, could see the dampening of the humanity which differienates us from machines;let’s hope not.

  14. Cath B. 2 February 2013

    Brilliantly put! As much as we’d sometimes like to “tune out” of technology, as it were, it is rather impossible to do so–we must be a part of this information age, yet still try to keep our human nature alive and vibrant through love, laughter, and yes, going to the toilet. And perhaps some good old fashioned letter writing and book reading.
    This is my first experience with The Junket and I think I shall be reading for a long time to come!

  15. Ilana 3 February 2013

    Is technology leading us back to our prehistoric small community? In the distant past everyone knew your business, the public and private were nearly identical. Now everyone may if you chose to let them know. The next step will be a broadcast from the toilet or the bedroom whether you wish it or not. It takes us back to the micro community where few personal secrets exist. The main difference is that we have some gatekeeper powers in shaping the community which softens perhaps our personal evolutionary path by providing more positively biased feedback ensuring less bumps and bruises.
    I see now that perhaps in the evolution of Dan Stevens acting maybe a developmental stage.

  16. Santha 5 February 2013

    Very nice piece! I appreciate the subtle methods you utilized to point out the contrast between the fear of technology and the esoteric potential it holds. As we integrate higher technology into our existence will we stay identified with the toy – losing ourselves
    in it – or will we use technology to serve us so we can focus on expressions of self and soul and contemplation. Beautiful !

  17. Chris 6 February 2013

    Though it was difficult for me to understand and the reading took some time – I am not a native speaker – I really enjoyed reading that piece and the others. They gave me something to think of! Good job, thank you! Hope you never stop writing.

  18. jcms 18 February 2013

    Appreciate deeply the quality writing and well-developed thought. Am passing the site on to my daughter’s lit teacher. Thank you for making this available.

  19. Martin Fass 18 February 2013

    I so much appreciate reading this valuable essay, and consider myself lucky to have learned of the entire thejunket.org. I will read more.

    Meanwhile, though, one benefit of your writing is the inspiration it has been giving me to work on an assignment, composing a few pages with the theme of Devotion. This, at least for me, has to do with the question of being devoted to what; serving people in need, becoming wealthy from investments, success as a popular entertainer, etc.

    Something has been growing over the past few decades, enveloped in a cloak of stealth. I’m aware of its presence now and then, but only briefly. Then I become distracted. In fact, distracting me, and others, might be a primary goal of this force or phenomenon or whatever it is, which comes before me via the computer, its keyboard and display…tempting me to stay amused and take nothing seriously for more than a moment.

    “Be devoted to a life of beauty and happiness,” this spectre whispers. And if I will consent to place an order, shipping is free!

    Thank you again, and all the best, Dan Stevens.

  20. Catie Cook 18 February 2013

    Engaging read. Well put. Thank you.

  21. sharmuse 19 February 2013

    Computers are a blessing and a curse. It may ultimately not be true, but it often seems that a computer is only as smart as the human that programs it. Tweeting is by far not the worst thing one can do in a restroom, but let’s not go there. :>)

  22. Yolanda 20 February 2013

    I am not a fan of twitter just because it pains me to have to follow the tweet further through a tiny URL. I am more a Facebook person, and fortunately, I haven’t seen anybody posting there that they are “taking care of business in the toilet”, yet. But, recently I went to Hawaii and I wanted to share some of my experiences with my friends and family. The possibility of downloading pictures of my adventures, and have almost instant feedback was exhilarating! I guess it is that instant feedback what prompts people to post tweets and FB updates.
    I also love the easiness of communication Facebook provides me. I like connect with other writers of books I like. I like when they share music or elements which gave them inspiration to write their story. I think writers, write, because they have the need to share. (Do computers feel the need to share?). If as a writer you have feedback from your readers, then you are not alone, even if the craft of writing is a lonely business.

    Thank you for pointing our attention to this online magazine. I always like thought provoking reads. It is funny to think how in our normal life, I, like most everybody would feel intimidated, and star struck if I were to find you in the street. The internet allows this communication to happen in an easier, and fluid way. I am sure that being famous sometimes isolates you. Writing brings people together.

    Thank you for sharing your true self with us readers.

  23. Sabina Petra 26 February 2013

    ‘Drop by drop we squeeze the slaves from ourselves’ – that’s wonderful.